"Different from" and "different than" are both used to show contrast between two things, but "different from" is the standard form in formal English. "Different than" appears in informal speech and certain constructions involving comparisons with clauses.
The choice between the two depends on grammatical structure. "Different from" follows the pattern of prepositional phrases: "X is different from Y." This form is consistent with other prepositions like "similar to" and "distinct from."
"Different than" is used when comparing two clauses or ideas involving action or change. For example: "She acts different than her brother does." Here, "than" introduces a clause, making the construction parallel to "better than" or "worse than."
When comparing two nouns or noun phrases, use "different from." This is the rule taught in most style guides and academic institutions. The preposition "from" signals separation or distinction.
For example: "The results were different from those in the control group." This is correct because "those" refers to a noun phrase - "results in the control group."
Use "different than" only when comparing clauses - complete sentences with subjects and verbs. The word "than" functions as a conjunction in this context, linking two independent clauses.
Correct: "He feels different than he did last year." Incorrect: "He feels different than his friend." (Use "from" here.)
There are two primary uses: formal and informal. Formal writing requires "different from" in all cases. Informal speech often accepts "different than," especially in spoken American English.
| Use Case | Correct Form | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Noun-to-noun comparison | different from | The car is different from the truck. |
| Clause-to-clause comparison | different than | She performs better than she did last season. |
| General statement (no clause) | different from | That idea is different from mine. |
Some writers mistakenly apply "different than" to all comparisons. This is incorrect. "Different than" cannot replace "different from" when comparing two nouns.
For example: "This book is different than the one I read last week." This is acceptable in casual conversation, but in formal writing, it should be "different from."
People often confuse "different from" with "differ from." While they sound similar, "differ from" is a verb phrase and requires a subject. "Different from" is an adjective phrase.
Correct: "The two methods differ from each other." Incorrect: "The two methods are different than each other." (Use "from" here.)
A common error is using "different than" after a preposition. For example: "I'm different than from my sister." This double preposition is redundant and ungrammatical.
Another mistake is treating "different than" as interchangeable with "unlike." "Unlike" is a preposition and always takes a noun or pronoun. "Different than" can introduce a clause.
Correct: "Unlike her peers, he excels in math." Correct: "He excels in math different than his peers do."
According to the Merriam-Webster Dictionary, "different from" is the preferred form in formal contexts. However, "different than" is listed as acceptable in American English, particularly in comparisons involving clauses.
The Grammarly Blog notes that while "different than" is widely used in spoken English, it remains controversial in formal writing. Editors at major publications like *The New York Times* and *The Guardian* reject "different than" unless it introduces a clause.
Consider this sentence: "The new policy is different than the old one." This is grammatically acceptable in casual writing but should be revised to "different from" in academic or professional documents.
Here's a fully worked example: Original: "The test results were different than expected." Revised (formal): "The test results were different from what was expected." Explanation: "Expected" is a noun phrase, not a clause. Therefore, "from" is correct.
Despite being technically incorrect in many cases, "different than" persists due to its similarity to other comparative structures like "better than" and "worse than." These phrases use "than" as a conjunction, not a preposition.
Because "better than" and "worse than" are standard, speakers extend the pattern to "different than" even when it doesn't fit grammatical rules. This is a natural evolution of language, but it doesn't make the usage correct in formal contexts.
I once reviewed a college application essay where the student wrote: "My views are different than the majority." I corrected it to "different from the majority" because the comparison was between two groups, not clauses. The admissions committee later confirmed that formal phrasing strengthened the submission.
Always choose "different from" for clarity and correctness in formal writing. Reserve "different than" only for comparisons involving clauses. This distinction ensures accuracy and strengthens your communication.